Thursday, April 09, 2015

Proposal: Too much avec in this one for my taste.

Timed out / quorum 8 votes to 0. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 12 Apr 2015 16:47:57 UTC

In rule Review, change:

A rating is an Integer value that can be positive, negative or 0.

Each Cook may post Recipes as comments beneath the newest Review blogpost. The last such post of each Cook is called the Entry Recipe and is rated in the next Review.

Reviewers follow a set rule on how to determine the Rating based on the Recipe.

to:

Each Cook may post Recipes as comments beneath the newest Review blogpost. The last such post of each Cook is called the Entry Recipe and is rated in the next Review.

Create a new rule, “Ratings”:

A rating is a String comprised of exactly 5 characters, that can be any combination of plus signs (+), minus signs (-), or asterisks (*) (alias: Stars). Possible spacing and the order of characters in a Rating are irrelevant, and should be kept consistent between ratings (eg: by putting all the asterisks fist and all pluses at the end).

The Restaurant Manager shall follow some set rules on how to determine the Rating based on the Recipe and on the Characteristics of the current Reviewer. These rules are:
* The Rating defaults to - - - - -.
* If the Recipe contains the Favourite Ingredient of the Reviewer, one minus is changed to a Star.
* For each Valued Property of the recipe that matches the Reviewer’s Sweet Spot for that Valued Property, one minus is changed to a Star.
* For each Valued Property of the recipe that exceeds the Reviewer’s Sweet Spot for that Valued Property, one minus is changed to a Plus.

Comments

mideg:

04-09-2015 13:11:52 UTC

In what order are these rules worked out? The order matters as shown in this example:

Four Sweet Spots have been exactly hit, meaning three Minuses are made Stars. One has been exceeded, meaning one Minus is made a Plus. Obviously, the favourite ingredient is in it, meaning another Minus is made a Plus. As you can see, six Minuses have been converted of the original 5.

Also, Vegetarianism isn’t considered at all and having 1 of each ingredient already makes your recipe at least 1 star.

Those points can be fixed, though, and I will just propose a fix and vote this up. :-)

for

severian:

04-09-2015 13:32:44 UTC

for

Kevan:

04-09-2015 13:59:08 UTC

for

Josh:

04-09-2015 16:32:23 UTC

for

Brendan:

04-09-2015 17:13:12 UTC

for

Darknight:

04-09-2015 21:05:10 UTC

for

Sylphrena:

04-10-2015 13:09:48 UTC

for