Monday, April 06, 2015

Proposal: You Say Tomato

Reaches quorum and passes, 8-0. Josh

Adminned at 08 Apr 2015 16:32:21 UTC

Replace “An Ingredients properties are fixed and known to the Restaurant Manager and may only be revealed to a Cook if the rules allow it.” with:-

An Ingredient’s properties are chosen by the Restaurant Manager, are fixed, and may be listed in brackets after their name in this list. (If an Ingredient has no properties listed, the Restaurant Manager should update this rule to include them.)

It feels a bit silly that we aren’t initially sure whether a lemon is more or less sour than a tomato. A subgame of “guess the Manager’s qualia of known real-world objects” (where lemons are obviously sour, but we aren’t sure if Mideg rates them a 4 or a 5) doesn’t seem very interesting, and anything else (“surprise, Lemons are spicy and not suitable for vegetarians!”) seems off-theme, from what we’ve got.

Comments

Brendan:

04-06-2015 19:41:09 UTC

for

mideg:

04-06-2015 20:35:52 UTC

for Fair enough. Guessing the Reviewers is more important anyway, I think.

Darknight:

04-06-2015 20:48:37 UTC

for

Sylphrena:

04-06-2015 21:30:12 UTC

for

Josh:

04-06-2015 21:33:29 UTC

for

Ely:

04-06-2015 21:36:36 UTC

for

severian:

04-07-2015 12:32:53 UTC

for