Monday, July 11, 2011

Again, no CFJ, but please be more careful, admins

My proposal “Proposal: Dying? I don’t care!” was adminned by Kevan. It was mostly legal, but this is nomic, so mostly legal is not enough.

In his adminning, Kevan did not include a tally of votes. My vote as an author was an implicit FOR, which was not counted. This is no problem in this case, but as the proposal didn’t change its status from pending because it was not properly adminned, any future adminning of proposals would have been illegal, too.

As always, I might be wrong, so I am happy about critics and comments. :-)

Comments

Kevan: HE/HIM

11-07-2011 13:23:03 UTC

Fixed to include the phrase “and only 1 FOR”.

mideg:

11-07-2011 17:04:21 UTC

Thanks! No hard feelings here, I just want to avoid the follow-up-problems.