Monday, November 14, 2011

Proposal: Anti-Looping Measures

Timed Out + Quorum. 13-0 (9-0-4). ~~Chronos Phaenon

Adminned at 16 Nov 2011 01:48:23 UTC

In the rule “Routes”, change the text

A Route is either Active or Inactive; Inactive Routes should be marked with a * to indicate this

to

A Route is either Active, Inactive or Blocked; Inactive Routes should be marked with a * and Blocked Routes with a ! to indicate this

and the text

Then, the first five Routes in their pool (or all if there are fewer), become Active.

to

Then, all the Blocked Routes in their pool become Inactive and the first five Routes in their pool (or all if there are fewer), become Active.

If a Rule named “Highway” exists append the following text to it:

Highway Routes become Blocked instead of Inactive when Driven.

If a Rule named “Scouting” contains the text

and adds that Route Inactive to the bottom of his list.

change it to

and adds that Route Blocked to the bottom of his list.

 

The key idea is that Blocked routes can’t be made Active except at Request Assignment time.  With Routes able to make other Routes active, this keeps newly bought Routes from ever being run on the same assignment-cycle, and removes the corner case where someone with only Highway Routes can loop them with all eir double-dailies.

Comments

PBURNS:

14-11-2011 05:13:26 UTC

for

ais523:

14-11-2011 11:43:50 UTC

imperial Seems good enough for reducing the space of viable scams. I’m not sure if that’s going to make the dynasty more or less interesting. (It’s at least likely to make it longer.)

scshunt:

14-11-2011 13:36:13 UTC

against since it doesn’t actually accomplish its goal. If it did, I would vote for.

Prince Anduril:

14-11-2011 14:17:13 UTC

imperial

Bucky:

14-11-2011 14:19:31 UTC

coppro: Explain please?

Clucky: he/him

14-11-2011 18:18:39 UTC

for

ChronosPhaenon:

14-11-2011 18:23:02 UTC

imperial

scshunt:

14-11-2011 19:03:31 UTC

Bucky: It just sets all blocked routes to inactive, then activates the first five. It doesn’t specify that it requires the route to not be blocked to be activated.

scshunt:

14-11-2011 19:03:56 UTC

No wait, I just now realize that that is the point. CoV for

Murphy:

14-11-2011 19:08:07 UTC

for per coppro (from the comments: “Blocked routes can’t be made Active except at Request Assignment time”, emphasis added)

SingularByte: he/him

14-11-2011 19:33:17 UTC

for

Ornithopter:

14-11-2011 20:37:58 UTC

for

Spitemaster:

15-11-2011 17:27:56 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

16-11-2011 00:22:35 UTC

for

Pavitra:

16-11-2011 02:40:29 UTC

imperial