Wednesday, May 12, 2021

Proposal: Art Makes The World Go Round

Adminned at 13 May 2021 03:38:48 UTC

Add a new Rule called “Rounds” with the following text

The game is split into a number of rounds. Rounds are performed in numerical increasing order starting with round 1, then round 2, etc… Rounds may be refered to by both phrases of the form “Round n” and “The nth Round”

If the current time is after the Expiration Date of the previous round (or that has been no previous round this dynasty), the Collector may start a round.

Give it a subrule called “Starting A Round” with the following text

To start a round, the Collector first makes a comment on the previous Round Post (if there is one from this dynasty) declaring the Round to be over. After this point, no more submissions for that round may be made. Then they perform the following atomic action, known as the Round Summary

* Begin a new story post to the blog titled “Round [x]” where x is one more than the previous round number (or 1, if it is the first round of the dynasty). This is known as the Round Post
* Determine a word or phrase to be the round’s Theme and declare what the new theme is in the Round Post
* Determine the Round’s Expiration Date by doing the following, and declare what the Expiration Date is on the Round Post
  - If the current time is before 17:00 UTC, set the new Round’s Expiration Date to be two calendar days later at 15:00 UTC (So if it is Thu 13/05/21—03:30 UTC, the expiration date will be Sat 15/05/21—15:00 UTC)
  - If the current time is at or after 17:00 UTC, set the new Round’s Expiration Date to be three days later at 15:00 UTC (So if it is Thu 13/05/21—23:30 UTC, the expiration date will be Sun 15/05/21—15:00 UTC)
* Submit the Round Post to the Blog

Add a new rule called “Submissions” with the following text

Submissions are private messages which may be sent from Sourcers to the Collector. The types of Submissions which can be made are subrules of this rule.

If the Collector is Clucky, direct messages with the Slack user named Clucky (UserID U0VQTMGUW) count as a valid means of communication with the Collector, and may be used in place of private messages. Any communication on the slack must clearly indicate which Sourcer is doing the communicating, and impersonating another Sourcer is in violation of fair play.

Submissions may be made at any time, provided the current round has not been closed. Any submission of a given type for a given round overrides previous submissions of that type made by the same Sourcer that round. Sourcers may also partially amend their submissions (“Such as change the title of my Art Submission to ___”)

Give it a subrule called “Art Submissions” with the following text

An Sourcer may submit an image, known as a piece of art, which they believe matches the current Round’s chosen Theme by messaging the Collector with a link to an image (or the an uploaded version of the image, if sent via slack) as well as a title for the piece. Titles are always flavor text, only used to identify the piece of art. The contents of a piece of art are also flavor text.

All art submitted must be appropriate for all ages. Art submissions containing art which the collector believes to be inappropriate or which the collector cannot load are not valid. If the Collector deems an Art Submission is not valid, they should at their earliest convenience inform the Sourcer who submitted it that the piece of art so that they may submit a different piece

Add a new rule called “Kudos” and give it the following text

Each Sourcer has an integer amount of Kudos, which defaults to 0. There is a public integer value of Kudos known as the Threshold, which by default is 0. To Update the Threshold means to set it to the Median value of all Sourcer’s Kudos

Open for 12 hours. Passes 9-0—Clucky

Comments

Josh: he/they

12-05-2021 15:45:36 UTC

Is it the intent that Sourcers can continue to submit art after a round’s expiration date but before the Collector formally closes it?

Josh: he/they

12-05-2021 15:48:27 UTC

What constitutes “All art submitted must be appropriate for all ages”?

Clucky: he/him

12-05-2021 16:05:39 UTC

> Is it the intent that Sourcers can continue to submit art after a round’s expiration date but before the Collector formally closes it?

I felt like it doesn’t hurt to allow late submissions. I suppose you could argue that this allows some unfair practices where sometimes someone gets to submit late and other times not. I’d be fine making it so that you need to get stuff in on time if that’s what people want, but think that might be better suited as its own proposal to get the whole blog’s feelings

> What constitutes “All art submitted must be appropriate for all ages”?

I feel like there is mostly a societal norm here as to what counts as “all ages”—nothing violent, nothing sexual, nothing political, etc… I don’t want to have to deal with someone submitting an inappropriate image and then having to retroactively force a rule through to deal with it. I also don’t want to have to give an explicit list of what is and isn’t allowed, because that leads to rules lawyering and sneaking stuff through. So I feel like the general “all ages” guideline and having it ultimately be my judgement call in the end is right but if you have better ideas on how to resolve the problem I’d love to hear them

Josh: he/they

12-05-2021 16:16:09 UTC

I feel like there is mostly a societal norm here as to what counts as “all ages”—nothing violent, nothing sexual, nothing political

I think that a quick scan of art history would suggest otherwise! Is the Venus de Milo too sexual, is Guernica too violent or political? I agree that for the first proposal of the dynasty that’s a thorny question but tbh the debates around this in the art world might be part of the entertainment - we may want to draw them out as a mechanic.

Clucky: he/him

12-05-2021 16:41:43 UTC

I think its definitely something we can revise as the dynasty goes along if needed. But I’d rather err on the side of caution and make adjustments to be less cautious as needed than to have to let some stuff through

pokes:

12-05-2021 17:22:38 UTC

for

Raven1207: he/they

12-05-2021 17:25:56 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

12-05-2021 18:11:56 UTC

for

Zack: he/him

12-05-2021 18:47:54 UTC

for

Josh: he/they

12-05-2021 20:13:10 UTC

for

Snisbo: she/they

12-05-2021 20:51:12 UTC

for

Janet: she/her

12-05-2021 21:36:47 UTC

for

lemon: she/her

12-05-2021 21:51:23 UTC

for