Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Proposal: Cleaning up useless rule text/

Self-killed. Josh

Adminned at 24 Nov 2011 00:48:39 UTC

In rule “Resolution of Proposals” change:

It could not be Enacted without either one of the Votes AGAINST it being changed, or the set of Drivers being changed, or by awaiting the passage of time.

to

It could not be Enacted without either one of the Votes AGAINST it being changed, or the set of Drivers being changed.

In rule “Victory and Ascension” change:

It has been open for voting for at least 12 hours, and it could not be Enacted without either at least one of the Votes AGAINST it being changed, or the set of Drivers being changed, or by awaiting the passage of time.

to

It has been open for voting for at least 12 hours, and it could not be Enacted without either at least one of the Votes AGAINST it being changed, or the set of Drivers being changed.

The ” awaiting the passage of time” bit is meaningless.

Comments

Spitemaster:

22-11-2011 01:37:57 UTC

for

scshunt:

22-11-2011 02:28:06 UTC

against as it serves to clear up edge cases by making sure that you don’t evalue ‘could not be enacted’ as an instantaneous condition.

Josh: Observer he/they

22-11-2011 07:29:36 UTC

for I missed that wording. As written, doesn’t it mean that the oldest proposal can be failed if it hasn’t timed out but would pass if it did?

ais523:

22-11-2011 11:26:59 UTC

for Without the “passage of time” wording, a proposal which had, say, 6 FORs (i.e. less than quorum) and 0 AGAINSTs could be immediately failed if it were at the back of the queue; because as it wouldn’t have been quorumed, it couldn’t be enacted without waiting for it to time out, and so if the rules don’t explicitly allow timing out as a method to allow a proposal to eventually pass, then if a proposal can’t be passed right now it can be failed.

ais523:

22-11-2011 11:27:21 UTC

err, CoV against, I used the wrong voting icon.

ChronosPhaenon:

22-11-2011 12:59:28 UTC

against Ok, per ais523, but I’ll repropose to make it clearer.

Cpt_Koen:

22-11-2011 22:07:00 UTC

against

Bucky:

23-11-2011 13:43:37 UTC

against