Friday, March 13, 2020

Proposal: Duello Ribbon

Popular, 9-2. Josh

Adminned at 15 Mar 2020 07:27:27 UTC

Replace the first paragraph and bulleted list of “Ribbons” with:-

There exist five Ribbons, which are (along with their Requirements):

* Ribbon of Letters: Own the Estate with the most Favour of the King Items.
* Ribbon of the Sword: Own the Estate with the most Military Items.
* Ribbon of the Bell: Own the Estate with the most Loyalty from a Vassal Items.
* Ribbon of the Robe: Own the Estate with the most Items.
* Ribbon of the Chancery: Have both the highest Prestige and the highest Power.

To the end of the rule, add:-

If a Nobleman is the only Nobleman to meet the Requirement of a Ribbon, they may (after removing it from any Nobleman who already holds it) hold that Ribbon.

Renaming the Academia/Tactics/Cunning/Charm/Supremacy ribbons after historical classes of French nobility, and giving a way to pick them up.

Comments

Clucky: he/him

13-03-2020 15:50:46 UTC

against

I worry this’ll put too fast of a timer on the game.

As soon as a single favor from the king, military item, or loyalty from a vassal item 4/5 ribbons will already be “in play”, and someone will already have two of them. So then as long as the 5th ribbon goes to someone else… its already game over.

Kevan: he/him

13-03-2020 15:53:06 UTC

Ribbons haven’t been connected to any kind of victory condition yet, you just become “the Champion”.

This will get them out there fast, but it’ll immediately slow down once the requirement for “most X” becomes greater than one.

Madrid:

13-03-2020 15:57:53 UTC

against because of game design interests, I’m aiming for having the auctions fuel sub-games.

Clucky: he/him

13-03-2020 16:04:58 UTC

CoV imperial

good point for some reason I just assumed being The Champion meant you won

I’m still a bit on the fence. Its weird to me that the 4/5 ribbons are connected to the same type of gameplay. I’d rather just go all in on tying ribbons to items (and swap the last ribbon with Romance items) or have only one be for collecting items and the other three be for other stuff.

Josh: Observer he/they

13-03-2020 16:08:43 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

13-03-2020 16:12:17 UTC

I was thinking of Auctions being the core of the game, and this just adding a layer of decisions to that when a new Item comes up: if a +1 Power Military Item is dealt and Robespierre already has the Ribbon of the Sword with 1 Military, do I bid more to draw level, does he bid more to keep his Ribbon safe, etc.

Having some Item types matter for Ribbons and some not seems more interesting than a straight one-for-one, I think.

Ninja:

13-03-2020 16:45:05 UTC

imperial

Brendan: he/him

13-03-2020 17:14:59 UTC

for

Darknight: he/him

13-03-2020 19:28:24 UTC

for

Lulu: she/her

13-03-2020 21:53:29 UTC

against

Tantusar: he/they

14-03-2020 10:20:47 UTC

for

Farsight:

14-03-2020 12:11:12 UTC

imperial

The Duke of Waltham: he/him

15-03-2020 01:02:00 UTC

for