Monday, May 02, 2022

Proposal: Lead Balloons

Reached quorum 6 votes to 0. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 03 May 2022 09:30:20 UTC

If a rule exists called “Facts on the Ground”, replace:-

When a Interpreted History Action is rendered invalid, either by a piece of Atlantean language gaining a concrete meaning that contraindicates the change made in the Interpreted History Action in question, or directly by the passage of a CfJ, or by the failure of a CfJ or DoV that attempted to establish its legitimacy, the Interpreted History Action in question may be reverted by any Memory of Atlantis and its entry may be removed from the log.

with:-

If a piece of Atlantean language gains a concrete meaning that contraindicates the change made by an Interpreted History Action, that Interpreted History Action in question may be rendered invalid and reverted by any Memory of Atlantis, with its entry removed from the log.

Not sure it’s necessary to bring CfJs and DoVs into this. Enacted CfJs can do what they want anyway, and reacting to negative-space failed CfJs and DoVs seems like trouble. I could raise a CfJ of “I win and also this IHA I don’t like is legitimate” to invalidate any IHA, and someone getting a DoV wrong for an unrelated reason would shut down any generally-accepted IHAs that it happened to be using, even if nobody objected to them.

Comments

Lulu: she/her

02-05-2022 14:33:47 UTC

for

MadisonSilver:

02-05-2022 18:36:16 UTC

for

Josh: Observer he/they

02-05-2022 19:26:10 UTC

for

Gozherd:

02-05-2022 20:07:34 UTC

for

SingularByte: he/him

03-05-2022 07:34:15 UTC

for