Friday, August 11, 2023

Proposal: Shouts to all my lost boys

Reached quorum 3 votes to 0. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 12 Aug 2023 17:53:28 UTC

If Proposal: We Rowdy was not enacted then this proposal has no further effect.

In the rule Commons, change “Each District may be connected to a number of Commons up to its population divided by 100, rounded up” to:

At any time a District may spend x*4 from their Energy Trap to establish a new Connection to a Commons, where x is their number of pre-existing Connections

Add an Upside to the rule Upsides and Downsides as follows:

* Gain 1 to your Energy Trap

Increase the Energy Trap of all Districts that don’t have a Connection by 4.

Per some comments on Discord, there are three problems with Commons at the moment: the people thresholds, the value of the commons being 0.1 of a benefit, and the imbalance in the Upside/Downside payoff. This attempts to address all three.

Comments

lemon: she/her

11-08-2023 12:28:10 UTC

i do think that making Commons this impactful would significantly diminish the Dilemmas as they currently stand. i like that we’re dealing with small quantities of food and people at the moment! is there a balance we could strike there, instead of making Commons give us such large quantities?

Josh: he/they

11-08-2023 12:50:29 UTC

I’m not sure that this massively increases volumes. Each Connection is essentially 1 Upside of value, and you have to take a Downside to capture it, so at 1 connection it’s a wash. If each Connection is 4 energy then at baseline we’ll each make a new one every 4 dilemmas on average, assuming a perfect distribution of Energy Traps, but the cost increases much faster than the availability of Energy is likely to, so in practice Commons are likely to end up yielding 2-3 Upsides in value at most. I’m not sure that we can lower that without making them pointless: it’s a strategy that rewards focus but not one that overwhelms the game imo.

Josh: he/they

11-08-2023 12:51:20 UTC

Also bear in mind that you still can’t access Commons without hitting a Govern dilemma, so I’m not sure how it can diminish the dilemmas

lemon: she/her

11-08-2023 13:01:10 UTC

i must be misunderstanding something here — as this is written, wouldn’t i be getting /eight food/ if i was connected to the Grazing Lands and Gathered right now? that seems crazy to me!

Josh: he/they

11-08-2023 13:07:19 UTC

Ahhhh. No, that’s on me. Hang on, will edit

Josh: he/they

11-08-2023 13:08:49 UTC

I’ve removed the change to the output weighting as it can be considered at a later time, so it should output as per the current system now.

lemon: she/her

11-08-2023 14:03:30 UTC

in that case, for!

JonathanDark: he/him

11-08-2023 14:29:05 UTC

for