Friday, September 13, 2019

Proposal: That’s No Pig

Timed out 3 votes to 2. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 15 Sep 2019 16:01:09 UTC

To “Hallucinations”, add:-

If a proposal has the tag “Hallucination” and its only proposed change to the ruleset and gamestate is the repeal of a single dynastic rule which has no subrules, it is considered a Hallucination Proposal. If a Castaway’s HSR is greater than the HSR of a Hallucination Proposal’s proposer, their vote on that Proposal is considered to be FOR (even if they have not voted on it, or have cast a different vote).

Comments

Brendan:

09-13-2019 16:21:27 UTC

for

Farsight:

09-13-2019 19:12:26 UTC

for

TyGuy6:

09-13-2019 19:53:38 UTC

Hmm. I have no HSR, but this would mean that anyone who has a low enough HSR can probably repeal any dynastic rule without subrules? I could go for it if it were more like 3 points more HSR, but this gathers votes from anyone just not paying attention. against

Thunder:

09-13-2019 22:24:43 UTC

against The lowest HSR getting unlimited repeals is probably bad.

Kevan:

09-14-2019 07:36:37 UTC

Since these are proposals, the lowest HSR player is capped at two repeals per day, and in practice that’d be slowed by other proposals in the queue.

Thunder:

09-14-2019 21:55:20 UTC

[Kevan] Costaways + this allows the traitor to create a substantial game delay by repealing a core mechanic or two.