Monday, June 03, 2019

Proposal: Toot one’s own horn

Self-killed. Failed by pokes.

Adminned at 04 Jun 2019 23:20:12 UTC

In “Civil Titles”, replace all occurrences of “is a civil title held by” with “is a civil title that may be claimed by”.

In “Drops”, after “When an Architect Builds, they must make a comment to that effect on the Drop post whose Block they Built.”, add:

This comment may optionally name one civil title that the Architect wants to claim. If they are able to claim that civil title, that Architect then holds it.

Comments

pokes:

03-06-2019 00:32:10 UTC

imperial I don’t feel strongly about this. It’s a manifestation of my not-a-proposal on “Award Ceremony”.

derrick: he/him

03-06-2019 02:04:55 UTC

against

Farsight:

03-06-2019 05:08:59 UTC

Do you not like it because of the way it is phrased? I like what the rule is trying to do, maybe just rephrase it?

Kevan: City he/him

03-06-2019 08:03:57 UTC

imperial Seems okay, but I think it needs the GNDT field proposed by Award Ceremony, to achieve what it’s trying to do. A player should be able to clearly see who (if anyone, including themselves) currently owns which title, when choosing which title to claim.

Farsight:

03-06-2019 08:14:20 UTC

Is there a way to add a note on the Moon Sites wiki page, so we can note the title we’re claiming on there?

The proposal might read something like:

“If an architect thinks they have achieved one or more Civil Titles, they may edit the Moon Sites page to claim that title/s.

If any architect or the supervisor thinks any claim to a Civil Title is incorrect, they may make a call for judgment to that effect. If the call for judgment is found to be justified, any architect may make the necessary changes to the Moon Sites page.”

This would mean each architect is responsible for making a title claim, while everyone else is responsible for checking they got it right.

Kevan: City he/him

03-06-2019 08:22:21 UTC

Would be fine to just say that “an Architect may claim a Civil Title they have achieved the criterion for, by updating the Moon Sites page” - the last paragraph of “Gamestate Tracking” already covers what to do about incorrect gamestate updates.

pokes:

04-06-2019 22:05:08 UTC

against S/K to hurry it up