Sunday, July 02, 2017

Proposal: [Core] [Dynastic] Triumvirate.

Fewer than a quorum not voting AGAINST. Failed 1 vote to 5 by Kevan.

Adminned at 03 Jul 2017 08:11:09 UTC

If Pokes, Kevan and Orkboi don’t vote FOR for this, this proposal does nothing.

Amend rule 1.3 “Dynasties” by replacing:

BlogNomic is divided into a number of Dynasties. Each Dynasty may be headed by a single Explorer, known as the Expedition Leader. If there is no Expedition Leader, the Dynasty is a Metadynasty.

with

BlogNomic is divided into a number of Dynasties. Each Dynasty may be headed by one or more Explorers, known as the Expedition Leaders. If there is no Expedition Leader, the Dynasty is a Metadynasty.

Add a new section called “Triumvirate”, within it, add:

The Explorers named Kevan, pokes and orkboi have achieved Victory and shall all three be the next Expedition Leaders of the next Dynasty.  Each of those Explorers may pass this role to another Explorer during the associated DoV by making a post to that effect, if they wish.

Contains copypasta from Koen’s proposal.

Comments

Cpt_Koen:

02-07-2017 18:08:44 UTC

against Did you just pick three Explorers at random ?

About the copy-pasting: there was an overwhelming majority of against votes on my Proposal. Kevan explained his vote, but he was pretty much the only one to do so. Sphinx even voted against while commenting it was a fine idea. I’d repropose something different if I knew what you didn’t like, but voting against while saying you like it makes it hard to respond.

card:

02-07-2017 18:10:01 UTC

Still doesn’t fix:
that a DoV can only make the author an Expedition Leader achieve victory
who determines the theme

Also that “Triumviarte” allows for infinite Dynasties, via one of them not repealing it during ascension.  against

Axemabaro:

02-07-2017 18:17:31 UTC

imperial

Cuddlebeam:

02-07-2017 18:24:05 UTC

@Koen: Not random. Those three can actually win by cointoss (amongst them) right now, so I find it appropriate for it to be them three.

Sphinx:

03-07-2017 07:49:04 UTC

@Koen: Sorry, I didn’t make that clear, I’m in favour of the idea, just not this specific execution (the issues mentioned by others).

against

Kevan: he/him

03-07-2017 07:58:51 UTC

against

Sphinx:

03-07-2017 08:17:36 UTC

(flavour-wise I would like the idea of all cultists melding together into a single explorer entity, I just don’t know how that could work in practice)