Thursday, May 04, 2023

Call for Judgment: Back to the Octagon!

Cannot be enacted, 1-7. Josh

Adminned at 04 May 2023 22:33:25 UTC

If Proposal: Failed Ultimatum was enacted, this CfJ does nothing. If it or any other DoVs are pending, fail them.

If any CFJs have been enacted since the posting of this CFJ, revert their changes; if any are still pending, fail them.

The City Architect named Misty ceases to be the City Architect.

Start a new Metadynasty by removing all dynastic rules, and by posting an Ascension Address with the title of “The Engineer Slam” and following body text:

TWO ENGINEERS ENTER. ONE ENGINEER LEAVES.

Add the following as a new rule to the ruleset:

In this dynasty, only the Engineers called Josh or Kevan may achieve Victory. If any other Engineer achieves Victory then they have instead not achieved Victory. This dynasty has no City Architect.
The Engineer called Josh may also be referred to as the Heel. The Engineer called Kevan may also be referred to as the Face.

Each Engineer is a member of a team; the teams are each captained by either the Heel or the Face, and the Heel and the Face may name their teams as they please, although the names of the teams are flavour text. Each Engineer’s team is publicly tracked.

As soon as possible, the Heel and the Face should conduct a public snake draft in the comments to a story post posted for that purpose, with the Heel picking first, selecting from the other Engineers in the game, until each Engineer in the same is in one or the others’ team. They should then update public tracking so that each Engineer’s team information is correct.

Whenever a Engineer becomes unidle for the first time in this dynasty they are added to the team of the Engineer who would have been next to pick in the initial snake draft.

Each Engineer has a Contribution score, which is a non-negative integer that defaults to zero. When the Heel or the Face achieve Victory in this dynasty they are encouraged to retain the Contribution scores of their team and ensure that they confer meaningful advantages to their holders in the next dynasty.

Idea and Most Text Stolen from Josh, and Heel and Face gotten from Tr4th is In The Biddle. This gives Josh their 50/50, ends the dynasty with a meta, and keeps some level of gamestate importance.

Comments

Benbot: he/him

04-05-2023 14:49:31 UTC

If there are any errors, please tell me.

Tantusar: he/they

04-05-2023 14:55:24 UTC

This would revert all passed CfJs ever. Players should not do that. I do not unidle.

Josh: Observer he/they

04-05-2023 14:55:58 UTC

Hahahahaha!

Why would I be the Heel? Clearly I am the Face in this situation.

Other than that I love it. Probably won’t vote for it as Kevan has not earned his 50% but I really appreciate the callback.

Tantusar: he/they

04-05-2023 14:57:02 UTC

(And quite apart from that (still idle) I think we need to get away from this particular fight, not make it more relevant.)

redtara: they/them

04-05-2023 15:12:59 UTC

Yes let’s make it impossible for anyone else to win for yet another dynasty, that’ll make everyone happy.

Benbot: he/him

04-05-2023 15:29:53 UTC

... sorry

Benbot: he/him

04-05-2023 15:31:07 UTC

Josh, who do you think would be a fair face?

Josh: Observer he/they

04-05-2023 15:48:55 UTC

I am surely the fairest face of all.

I don’t actually think that a 1v1 setup works here. A 1vAll setup might be more appropriate.

Benbot: he/him

04-05-2023 15:52:44 UTC

Could you draft something like that up… if Meta-Dynasty fails that’s the most likely thing to work.

Josh: Observer he/they

04-05-2023 15:55:34 UTC

Nah. I really don’t want a metadynasty. I’ll accept one if it’s forced on me but I’m not thrilled about how this whole situation is playing out.

Benbot: he/him

04-05-2023 17:53:29 UTC

(Josh) also the reason I gave you Heel is I’ve seen most people trying to prevent you from winning, so assuming auidence follows majority you’d be heel. :)

redtara: they/them

04-05-2023 18:16:57 UTC

against

Kevan: he/him

04-05-2023 18:22:11 UTC

against

Josh: Observer he/they

04-05-2023 19:13:03 UTC

against

Bucky:

04-05-2023 19:37:49 UTC

against following Kevan and Josh.

summai:

04-05-2023 20:38:25 UTC

against per Tantusar

JonathanDark: he/him

04-05-2023 21:36:53 UTC

against

redtara: they/them

04-05-2023 22:00:09 UTC

against

Habanero:

04-05-2023 22:24:23 UTC

against

Brendan: he/him

04-05-2023 23:04:06 UTC

against Tempting, though.