Sunday, September 25, 2011

Call for Judgment: If you’re in the water, hang onto your items

Timed out 0 votes to 4. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 29 Sep 2011 09:18:05 UTC

Wooble attempted today to Throw an Item Off board at 25/09 16:28 (UTC), when he was ejected on 24/09 21:25 (UTC).

The rules on throwing items off board state:

As a daily action, any Survivor who is not Dead may Throw an Item they own Off Board. They shall remove this Item from their Possession.

The rules for ejection state:

The first time any comment is posted by a Survivor other than the original poster which contains a FOR Vote then the Victim is temporarily ejected from the lifeboat. When this happens they lose 1 Sanity, cannot perform any Daily or Weekly actions or Eat or Sleep for the rest of that Day or for the duration of the following Day

Thus, Wooble illegally performed an action, in Throwing his Item off board.

I therefore propose his actions be reverted (he regains the Item) and he lose 1 Sanity as a penalty.

Feel free to make another CfJ if you feel a penalty is too harsh.

Comments

Kevan:

09-25-2011 16:48:21 UTC

against CfJs should only be raised “if two or more Survivors actively disagree as to the interpretation of the Ruleset” - Wooble may have merely overlooked this rule, rather than “actively disagreeing”. A simple revert of his action would have been enough, and he could have raised a CfJ if he did actually have an argument in favour of his action.

And yes, the Sanity penalty seems a bit harsh and arbitrary.

Kevan:

09-25-2011 16:50:10 UTC

I’ve gone ahead and reverted his action in the GNDT.

bateleur:

09-25-2011 18:52:11 UTC

against Per Kevan, who saved me some typing. :-)

(The conspiracy theorist in me wonders if there’s some reason why you needed Wooble to lose a Sanity!)

Blacky:

09-25-2011 21:50:40 UTC

against per Kevan

Ienpw III:

09-26-2011 01:22:20 UTC

Technically you can’t undo an illegal action (because it never happened in the first place).

Prince Anduril:

09-26-2011 15:36:27 UTC

Fair enough, so I’m meant to revert the action in the GNDT, and then if he disagrees, he can raise a CfJ?

Darknight:

09-28-2011 01:23:56 UTC

against