Friday, April 29, 2022

Proposal: Is this going to be fun? I don’t know

Withdrawn. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 01 May 2022 09:41:08 UTC

Add a new dynastic rule to the ruleset, called Facts on the Ground:

Memories of Atlantis may take actions based on their understanding of instructions of the ruleset that are wholly or partially in Atlantean, where that Atlantean does not have an agreed, tracked meaning; such an action is a Interpreted History Action.

All Interpreted History Actions must be publicly tracked in a log, along with the section of ruleset that justified it and the precise gamestate change that was made as a result of the interpretation.

When a Interpreted History Action is rendered invalid, either by a piece of Atlantean language gaining a concrete meaning that contraindicates the change made in the Interpreted History Action in question, or directly by the passage of a CfJ, or by the failure of a CfJ or DoV that attempted to establish its legitimacy, the Interpreted History Action in question may be reverted by any Memory of Atlantis and its entry may be removed from the log.

Comments

SingularByte: he/him

29-04-2022 14:21:45 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

29-04-2022 14:49:39 UTC

against

Would allow someone to interpret a symbol to mean “I am Emperor for life and no Arguments or CfJs or DoVs can be made”.

SingularByte: he/him

29-04-2022 15:06:32 UTC

I was just about to comment that you can’t stop CFJs since the Calls For Judgement rule can’t be overruled, but actually on thinking about it, you could still declare that you have the ability to counteract any votes on it or similar.
CoV against

Josh: Observer he/they

29-04-2022 15:12:14 UTC

against Withdrawn; I’ll repropose but tighter