Thursday, September 25, 2014

Proposal: Quick Change

Timed out 3 votes to 4. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 29 Sep 2014 00:49:02 UTC

To the first paragraph of the rule “The Players’ Equipment”, add:-

While the Ball is Out of Play, any Player may trade Shirt numbers with any other Player.

Comments

Bucky:

25-09-2014 14:29:45 UTC

against .  You want the shirt off my back, too?

Kevan: City he/him

25-09-2014 14:32:14 UTC

Nope, but if we’re now playing a game of “everybody versus the goalkeeper”, as proposed by the goalkeeper, there should perhaps be a way for the goalkeeper to change.

Person93:

25-09-2014 15:55:42 UTC

Shouldn’t the other player have some say in the matter?

ayesdeeef:

26-09-2014 03:00:14 UTC

Person93, well, if that’s what you believe, then by all means vote against this. However, I can tell you that switching a player’s shirt without giving them a say in the matter probably won’t hurt their feelings, and this Proposal is just for another element of strategy in the game. Even the shirt numbers are just strategic elements (although Doc may be in love with his shirt)

As for my vote, life should be fair… BUCKY *cough cough, but I don’t know if this is the best or most realistic way to do it.

Person93:

26-09-2014 03:55:36 UTC

I don’t think that the player should be able to outright refuse, perhaps if someone wants to change shirts, they should roll the dice and if they score before a certain number, then the other player has the option to refuse.

ayesdeeef:

26-09-2014 18:20:16 UTC

Person93, you should propose that.

Teninten:

26-09-2014 23:30:44 UTC

imperial

ayesdeeef:

28-09-2014 02:35:43 UTC

for

Sylphrena:

28-09-2014 03:51:15 UTC

against

Sprucial:

28-09-2014 04:45:33 UTC

against

BellEt:

28-09-2014 07:27:43 UTC

against

Teninten:

29-09-2014 03:32:11 UTC

People should vote; this is taking a long time