Saturday, August 22, 2009

Proposal: Setting things straight (through legal means, please)

Vetoed. - Qwazukee

Adminned at 22 Aug 2009 11:58:47 UTC

If Proposal “DoV Fixes” fails, this Proposal does nothing.

Create a new rule “arthexis is a cheating groundhog”:

arthexis may not post a Declaration of Victory. If the current month is September, any Bill Murray may repeal this rule.

Revert all gamestate and ruleset changes made by proposal “DoV Fixes”.

First: Yuri’s proposal is in bad style. It creates an effect that cannot be tracked ruleswise. We normally frown upon that.
Second: While I still believe my move was valid and was illegaly declared illegal, I will not fool myself either. Blognomic is about popular voting, not about rules. As such, even if my action was rules-based, if the other players wish to censure my action, that’s ok. It’s the way the game is played and I have no problems with that. But if you wanna bar me from winning, at least do it correctly and don’t mess up with the core rules.



08-22-2009 16:43:50 UTC

against  September should clearly state that it’s in 3009 as opposed to 2009.


08-22-2009 16:44:51 UTC

It doesn’t matter. As long as it is September, one can repeal it. Your point is a non issue.


08-22-2009 16:46:29 UTC

But it could be repealed this millennium! We need to fix it!


08-22-2009 16:49:11 UTC

Furthermore, yuri’s is even worse: it doesn’t say on WHICH five days I can’t make DoVs.


08-22-2009 16:56:29 UTC

But what if someone repeals it this year? You might be able to win!!


08-22-2009 18:58:18 UTC

veto The punishment, if you believe you have broken the rules, is a BAN. So unless that’s what you want, arht, then please focus on playing the game.