Sunday, August 01, 2010

Proposal: Suchlike?

Timed out 11 votes to 2. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 03 Aug 2010 01:18:00 UTC

Amend Rule 2.1.4.1 by replacing

If a Story Post ever has at least five comments that contain the ARROW (arrow.gif) icon, without including more than one comment from each Citizen, then the author of that Story Post may add one perversity point to their total in the GNDT. They may only do this within one week of making the Story Post, and may only gain one Perversity Point per Story Post.

with

If a Story Post ever has at least five comments authored by different Citizens that each contain the ARROW (arrow.gif) icon, then the author of that Story Post may add one perversity point to their total in the GNDT. They may only do this within one week of making the Story Post, and may only gain one Perversity Point per Story Post.

My interpretation of the current text is that it disqualifies any story post with multiple comments from the same citizen.

Comments

glopso:

01-08-2010 04:26:38 UTC

against  It only disqualifies the additional points

lilomar:

01-08-2010 04:43:53 UTC

for I think they both say the same thing, but your way is clearer.

ais523:

01-08-2010 04:49:12 UTC

for The current wording is broken in that if anyone posts twice on the Story Post, they make arrow perversity impossible on it. Thus, why the change is needed.

lilomar:

01-08-2010 04:53:53 UTC

Ah, I see now, comma-misuse on my part.

Bucky:

01-08-2010 05:00:23 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

01-08-2010 07:44:37 UTC

for

Wakukee:

01-08-2010 08:03:56 UTC

imperial

Darknight: he/him

01-08-2010 08:39:13 UTC

for

Purplebeard:

01-08-2010 09:39:49 UTC

for

Galdyn:

01-08-2010 12:55:13 UTC

for

flurie:

01-08-2010 13:14:10 UTC

for

Keba:

01-08-2010 22:44:24 UTC

Hm, I can see your point, but I don‘t like the arrow mechanism, so it‘s cleverer to vote against a fixing proposal, right? Well, then against

Darknight: he/him

02-08-2010 02:53:56 UTC

TREASON

90000:

02-08-2010 17:40:42 UTC

imperial