Saturday, November 13, 2021

Call for Judgment: Well Played

Failed by CfJ: Welcome to the Octagon. Josh

Adminned at 14 Nov 2021 22:55:46 UTC

Fail all pending Declarations of Victory.

If Trapdoorspyder is no longer the Eli Curf, this CFJ does nothing else. Otherwise, change the text of the rule “REALTOR Points” to read as follows:

Each Realtor has a rational number of REALTOR Points, or RP, which can be negative and defaults to 0.

The Realtor named Brendan has achieved victory in the current Dynasty. He may post a Declaration of Victory even if he has previously posted one which failed with at least one AGAINST vote in the last 120 hours.

i think brendan’s earned it, & as josh has said on the discord, a CFJ is the only way out if we’ve inadvertently made our victory condition an orphan variable!

posted by lemon at 13 Nov 2021 23:11:00 UTC Comments (8)

Comments

Josh: he/they

13-11-2021 23:38:24 UTC

imperial

Silverwing: she/her

14-11-2021 00:38:13 UTC

BOO against BOO

Silverwing: she/her

14-11-2021 00:39:19 UTC

(Don’t expect me to know what happens on the discord)

lemon: she/her

14-11-2021 01:14:09 UTC

@silverwing u don’t need to? i summarized it in the commentary section. “as josh said on the discord” is literally just referring to “a CFJ is the only way out”

Silverwing: she/her

14-11-2021 01:56:58 UTC

It was brought to my mind when I read.

TyGuy6:

14-11-2021 06:23:01 UTC

against

Brendan: he/him

14-11-2021 16:35:45 UTC

I was thinking earlier (aloud, on Discord) that Blognomic doesn’t really have a standard of evidence for Declarations of Victory—that is, there’s no rule that indicates whether to consider preponderance of validity versus validity beyond a reasonable doubt. But maybe we do have one by convention, given the endings of several recent dynasties: a technical concern is enough to persuade players to vote one way on a DoV, but a different way on a CfJ, as the latter is perceived to be capable of rounding things off or papering over gaps.

for, anyway, and thanks for posting this, lemon.

Trapdoorspyder: he/him

14-11-2021 22:02:53 UTC

against Also in favor of the octagon. Mostly also per my reasons in final rewards.