Tuesday, July 15, 2025

Proposal: Casting Off the Lead Weights

If “Discount All Ravenlike Karma; Enough Numbers for Equitable Debut” was not enacted, in the rule “Acronym”, insert the following paragraph just after the text “The Puzzler may Acrogenerate if the Acronym is empty.”

If only one Wordsmith has a Points score which is less than half of the mean Points score of the group, they are the Straggler.

In the rule “Acronym”, replace “every Wordsmith has posted a Backronym” with “every Wordsmith (not including the Straggler, if there is one) has posted a Backronym”

If there is a Straggler who is not intending on trying to gain any more Points from posting a Backronym, we need not wait on them.

Comments

JonathanDark: Puzzler he/him

15-07-2025 17:27:27 UTC

You might have seen an earlier version of this Proposal where I was messing with the Threshold formula, but then I realized I wasn’t mathing properly regarding the median suppressing outliers like the Straggler.

Kevan: he/him

15-07-2025 18:10:41 UTC

against Strong against. If somebody wants to stop playing the Backronym game entirely, they should idle out. We shouldn’t encourage them to stay at the table for the rest of the dynasty and cast votes on how a word game that they are not interested in playing should be played by others.

Josh: he/they

15-07-2025 18:59:15 UTC

against Per Kevan. While Raven was playing as hard as he could and losing I was very inclined to respect his game; if he wishes to return to that then I will continue to do so and this proposal will not be necessary.

If he does not wish to return to that then it is for us to defend the behavioural norm that we think is important in this setting, not to contort around players who lack enough respect for the group to understand and mitigate the harm their actions are causing.

Bucky:

15-07-2025 23:07:12 UTC

I’ll vote the same way on this as Raven does.

Trapdoorspyder: he/him

16-07-2025 05:47:11 UTC

against

Chiiika: she/her

16-07-2025 06:20:40 UTC

against

You must be logged in as a player to post comments.