Monday, January 25, 2010

Proposal: Shhhh… again

Self-killed. -Ornithopter

Adminned at 26 Jan 2010 12:36:07 UTC

Create a new rule called “Deathly Quiet” with the following text:

A Guest is not allowed to create, or respond to, any story posts that discusses which Guests may or may not be the Murderers or Detectives if their Status is currently Dead. This rule does not prevent a Guest from voting on a proposal.

Add the following to the end of the function of the roles called “Vicar” and “Spiritualist”:

As a weekly action, the Vicar and/or the Spiritualist may make a story post asking two questions to one named Guest whose Status is currently Dead. The Guest can only answer with the following: Yes or No

 

Lets try again lol. Dropped the rider, added that dead guests can still vote but can’t make or comment on story posts involving trying to figure out whos a murderer and so on.

Comments

Kevan: he/him

25-01-2010 10:09:56 UTC

against This seems a bit toothless, if dead guests can still speculate and share as much game information as much as they like in proposal flavour text, other comments, or on IRC. Either we let them talk as much as they like, or we strictly limit what they can talk about.

The Werewolf Dynasty had a rule that prevented any discussion of information the dead player had learned or deduced while they were alive, which seemed about right. If you’d amassed some data or theories about the other players, you should make sure to share them with someone you trust before you die, rather than being assured that you could just chat about them in a comment thread if you ever got killed.

redtara: they/them

25-01-2010 11:44:51 UTC

against Per Kevan.

Keba:

25-01-2010 13:57:57 UTC

against As i am a Spiritulaist, I know dead people can speak, cant they? ;)

Seriously:  against Per Kevan.

alethiophile:

25-01-2010 13:58:22 UTC

against

Hix:

25-01-2010 14:30:27 UTC

against

spikebrennan:

25-01-2010 15:55:32 UTC

against

Oze:

25-01-2010 17:33:35 UTC

against

Rodlen:

25-01-2010 19:08:26 UTC

against

Ornithopter:

25-01-2010 21:25:55 UTC

against
This is more specific than the other one, which was already too specific.

Purplebeard:

25-01-2010 21:40:32 UTC

against

Darknight: he/him

26-01-2010 01:18:34 UTC

against can’t say i didn’t try lol. sk