Failed by CfJ. -Purplebeard
Adminned at 17 Dec 2010 02:50:08 UTC
Two scams at work here, either or both of which may be pushing my luck, but here we go.
First, the CfJ. The rules on passing CfJs state that:
All Divinities may cast Votes on that CfJ to indicate agreement or disagreement with the position taken in that CfJ. Unfailed CfJs continue until they reach a Quorum of FOR Votes, a Quorum of AGAINST Votes, or if there is no hiatus going on, until four days have passed, and if there is a hiatus going on until two days have passed. After this time, if more than half the cast Votes are FOR Votes, the CfJ may be enacted by any Admin by updating or correcting the Gamestate and Ruleset as specified. Otherwise, the CfJ fails. A Failed CfJ has no further effect.
The vulnerability here is that the rule doesn’t specify what the four days are relative to; the posting of the CfJ, the start of the dynasty, my cat dying, anything. I’m interpreting it as four days having passed ever, and if this DoV passes (and even if it doesn’t) then that should probably be fixed fairly urgently.
The second scam is clearer. I created a child named “The first Divinity to Meddle with this mortal achieves Victory”, then meddled with it. As the child is gamestate, and its name is also gamestate, that means that its name is interpretable as a condition as well as a generic signifier. I successfully fulfilled its conditions and thus achieved my win.
This does rely on an acceptance of my interpretation of Purplebeard’s attempted birth block, but again, that should be pretty clear: if Svetlana was not gamestate then the CfJ against her was illegal and she should have just been removed. The CfJ existed at all because her status was debatable, and in that regard she should be considered to remain gamestate until legally removable.